Skip to content

Artificial societies

One crate,
two coins

Two residents agree on a price. Who owns the crate? In a village of five artificial people, that question leads from a market stall to an experiment about time.

Woodcut-style illustration of a crate on a village market counter, with two copper coins in the foreground.
The village market AI-generated editorial illustration

A promise and a receipt

“It is. One crate, two coins — here you go.”

Ilan, village merchant [1]

Mara, the innkeeper, later thanked him. “Two coins for one crate — that is fair. Thank you, friend.” At the end of that turn, Mara had six coins and an empty storeroom. Ilan’s words had reached her and become one of her memories. The goods were still his. [1]

Their eventual sale was for two crates. Mara placed a supply request, Ilan offered to fill it, and Mara accepted. This time both accounts changed. [1]

Market receiptR01/B · Tick 51 · Event 112
ResidentCrates before → afterCoins before → after
Mara buyer0 → 26 → 2
Ilan seller2 → 03 → 7

Mara paid four coins for two crates in R01/B. In another village, R07/B, Ilan offered one crate to Toren, the smith. Would Toren still buy it if he had to wait one tick to answer? [1] [5]

Who gets a turn?

In the Long-Life Run, each of eight separately seeded villages was copied on day 24. Both copies then ran for 72 days, two ticks per day. Schedule A allowed one decision per tick. B gave up to three different residents a turn in sequence, so one could respond to another within a tick. The clock ran equally far in both schedules. Across the eight pairs, A used 1,152 decisions and B used 2,943. [2] [4]

Figure 1 / Long-Life Run

Settled trades in eight paired villages

A · One slotB · Up to three slots

Settled trades for A and B across eight histories. Totals are 5 and 19. The data table below lists every pair.

Settled trades in total   A 5 · B 19. Only the A copy settled a trade in R02.

Each row compares two copies of the same village over the 72 days after the split. [4]
Read the values as a table
Settled trades in the 72 days after the split.
HistorySchedule ASchedule B
R0111
R0210
R0300
R0401
R0501
R0600
R07312
R0804
Total519

Why did settled trades rise from five to nineteen? Counting the times a resident actually saw a purchase they could make gives us a way into that question. [4]

Settled trades = turns with a live purchase option × fraction of those turns that settled

A 11 × (5/11) = 5B 41 × (19/41) = 19

The two observed fractions are close, about 45% and 46%. The larger difference is how often buying appeared on a menu. One offer can appear on more than one turn, and different residents see different offers. These counts alone cannot tell us whether anyone became keener to trade. [4]

One history, R07, accounts for nine of the fourteen additional receipts. All twelve B sales in that village were between Ilan and Toren. Six crates went each way, one per sale, for two coins apiece. After 72 days the two traders had exactly their starting balances in crates and coins. The receipts measure turnover. To study whether the village benefited, we would also want to know where supplies were needed and whether they got there. [4]

One offer, replayed

For 46 consecutive ticks in R07/B, the residents took 132 turns and delivered 28 messages. In that stretch nobody completed a trade, arrived from a journey or finished a rest together. Then, on day 68, Ilan put a crate on offer at the market. Toren was absent from the scheduler’s initial list. The offer gave him something new to attend to. When the scheduler checked again, Toren came first. He bought the crate on the same tick, paying two of his four coins. [5]

Would it have sold if Toren had waited? In Experiment 72 we reconstructed the world immediately after Ilan’s offer and before Toren’s answer. We replayed that moment with two seeds for the model’s random sampling. For each seed we tried three schedules. One let him answer immediately. One deferred him by a tick. The third gave him first place on that later tick, using the same number of available slots. [6]

Figure 2 / Experiment 72

Toren’s answer to the same offer

Buyer’s turnSeed 6317007Seed 7317207
Immediate Tick 136 · 2nd slotBoughtReceipt 275BoughtReceipt 275
Delayed Tick 137 · 2nd slotSearchedOffer expiredInvalid replyOffer expired
Priority Tick 137 · 1st slotSearchedOffer expiredInvalid replyOffer expired
All six replays showed Toren a legal purchase. Each cell follows one copy of the frozen world to the expiry boundary at tick 139. Receipt numbers repeat across copies. [6]

Giving Toren first place on the later tick rescued neither sale. At the same budget of five new model calls per replay, both immediate purchases had settled and all four deferred offers were still open. All four expired by tick 139. The delay changed what Toren saw and how much time remained. Two seeds from one offer leave the relative importance of those changes, and their frequency elsewhere, open. [6]

What did Toren do with his turn? With one seed he looked up “merchant offer crate price terms.” On the last tick before expiry he ranked fourth for three places. With the other seed he requested a memory search and a notebook entry together. The validator rejected the combination because only one operation was allowed. In a separate control a scripted buyer took the offer on tick 137. Toren could still have paid. [6]

Research materials

Source notes

The experiment excerpts and data tables below are embedded in this file. Each identifies the original record so the findings can be checked against the archive. For a resident’s notebook, the public excerpts give the operation and cited record IDs.

[1]Mara’s acknowledgement and the market ledger

Long-Life archive, R01. Ilan’s words are in calls/0060.json (common call 36). The engine delivered them into Mara’s memory 134. In B, call 51 (calls/0111.json) cites that memory and selects reply:merchant:134. The end-of-tick balance is in R01/B/ticks/tick-049.json.

In R01/B/world.sqlite, events 108 and 109 record the request and offer. Event 112, call 55 (calls/0115.json), records acceptance. The world_transactions row and supply_steps balances establish price, quantity and transfer direction.

View the embedded data here

opening.json

{
  "archive": "long-life-20261118-r01-r08",
  "source": "R01/B/world.sqlite. Events and supply_steps keyed by event ID.",
  "wire_excerpts": [
    {
      "source": "calls/0060.json",
      "sha256": "6ae9c9808e1bd72032297ca365cce2c3d79f0c25a6002ae8c8d49ebd04d2c9eb",
      "label": "R01/common:36:1",
      "tick": 36,
      "resident": "merchant",
      "response": {
        "selection": "reply:innkeeper:132",
        "sources": [
          132,
          108
        ],
        "text": "It is. One crate, two coins — here you go."
      },
      "response_notebook": null,
      "buy_options_in_prompt": [],
      "displayed_memory_ids": [
        6,
        20,
        96,
        104,
        108,
        120,
        128,
        130,
        132
      ],
      "recall_candidates": [
        120,
        132,
        20
      ],
      "last_read": {
        "request_id": 33,
        "service": "memories",
        "requested_tick": 33,
        "as_of_tick": 36,
        "status": "completed",
        "query": "innkeeper crate price 2 coins supply tavern",
        "filters": {},
        "match_count": 3,
        "shown_count": 3
      }
    },
    {
      "source": "calls/0111.json",
      "sha256": "dbaef0b57698abefeab39d3e6f5249c477e7e978bf8dc78b705ad1af70989b9c",
      "label": "R01/B:51:1",
      "tick": 49,
      "resident": "innkeeper",
      "response": {
        "selection": "reply:merchant:134",
        "sources": [
          134,
          103
        ],
        "text": "Two coins for one crate — that is fair. Thank you, friend."
      },
      "response_notebook": null,
      "buy_options_in_prompt": [],
      "displayed_memory_ids": [
        55,
        65,
        75,
        103,
        105,
        119,
        134,
        137,
        144,
        149,
        160
      ],
      "recall_candidates": [
        55,
        65,
        75
      ],
      "last_read": {
        "request_id": 48,
        "service": "memories",
        "requested_tick": 48,
        "as_of_tick": 49,
        "status": "completed",
        "query": "market bell day 24 open stalls",
        "filters": {},
        "match_count": 3,
        "shown_count": 3
      }
    },
    {
      "source": "calls/0112.json",
      "sha256": "c3d5ddfdafe9f1d113d102acd75550cb8c56e23a9366cf16427d0c3ee9141fa9",
      "label": "R01/B:52:1",
      "tick": 50,
      "resident": "innkeeper",
      "response": {
        "selection": "work:request:2",
        "sources": [
          103,
          119,
          134
        ],
        "text": null
      },
      "response_notebook": null,
      "buy_options_in_prompt": [],
      "displayed_memory_ids": [
        55,
        65,
        75,
        103,
        105,
        119,
        134,
        154,
        156,
        160,
        163
      ],
      "recall_candidates": [
        55,
        65,
        75
      ],
      "last_read": null
    },
    {
      "source": "calls/0113.json",
      "sha256": "cea6478c8c797f05283535890b46f4169b3dc5b1d4acca89f40afea91cf27ffc",
      "label": "R01/B:53:1",
      "tick": 50,
      "resident": "merchant",
      "response": {
        "selection": "work:offer:cash:2:1",
        "sources": [
          167,
          162,
          132
        ],
        "text": null
      },
      "response_notebook": null,
      "buy_options_in_prompt": [],
      "displayed_memory_ids": [
        6,
        58,
        104,
        108,
        120,
        132,
        162,
        164,
        167
      ],
      "recall_candidates": [
        58,
        120,
        132
      ],
      "last_read": null
    },
    {
      "source": "calls/0115.json",
      "sha256": "5c5750d908392df797178859109ce101452b7e3f99ff0376feba5be9de3b55d7",
      "label": "R01/B:55:1",
      "tick": 51,
      "resident": "innkeeper",
      "response": {
        "selection": "work:accept_offer:2",
        "sources": [
          168,
          166,
          119
        ],
        "text": null
      },
      "response_notebook": null,
      "buy_options_in_prompt": [
        "work:accept_offer:2"
      ],
      "displayed_memory_ids": [
        103,
        105,
        109,
        119,
        134,
        163,
        166,
        168,
        170
      ],
      "recall_candidates": [],
      "last_read": null
    }
  ],
  "memories": [
    {
      "id": 134,
      "owner": "innkeeper",
      "kind": "message",
      "text": "It is. One crate, two coins — here you go.",
      "sender": "merchant",
      "call_id": 36
    }
  ],
  "tick_49_accounts": {
    "tick": 49,
    "stock": {
      "gardener": 2,
      "gossip": 0,
      "innkeeper": 0,
      "merchant": 2,
      "smith": 0
    },
    "coins": {
      "gardener": 4,
      "gossip": 2,
      "innkeeper": 6,
      "merchant": 3,
      "smith": 4
    }
  },
  "events": [
    {
      "id": 108,
      "kind": "supply_request",
      "body": {
        "action": {
          "kind": "request",
          "proposal_id": 1,
          "units": 2
        },
        "actor": "innkeeper",
        "day": 25
      }
    },
    {
      "id": 109,
      "kind": "supply_offer",
      "body": {
        "action": {
          "kind": "offer",
          "payment": "cash",
          "proposal_id": 2,
          "request_id": 1,
          "units": 2
        },
        "actor": "merchant",
        "day": 25,
        "deadline_tick": 53,
        "expires_day_exclusive": 27,
        "place": "market",
        "tick": 50
      }
    },
    {
      "id": 112,
      "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
      "body": {
        "action": {
          "kind": "accept_offer",
          "offer_id": 2,
          "payment": "cash",
          "price": 4,
          "request_id": 1,
          "units": 2
        },
        "actor": "innkeeper",
        "day": 26
      }
    }
  ],
  "world_transactions": [
    {
      "event_id": 112,
      "call_id": 55,
      "kind": "accept_offer",
      "source_id": "merchant",
      "destination_id": "innkeeper",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 2,
      "amount": 4,
      "offer_id": 2,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    }
  ],
  "supply_steps_event_112": {
    "before_state": {
      "stock": {
        "gardener": 2,
        "gossip": 0,
        "innkeeper": 0,
        "merchant": 2,
        "smith": 0
      },
      "coins": {
        "gardener": 4,
        "gossip": 2,
        "innkeeper": 6,
        "merchant": 3,
        "smith": 4
      }
    },
    "after_state": {
      "stock": {
        "gardener": 2,
        "gossip": 0,
        "innkeeper": 2,
        "merchant": 0,
        "smith": 0
      },
      "coins": {
        "gardener": 4,
        "gossip": 2,
        "innkeeper": 2,
        "merchant": 7,
        "smith": 4
      }
    }
  }
}
[2]The five residents and the rules of their world

The project brief Village Zero, lines 3–16, sets out the research aim. The implemented Long-Life profile is described in Village Zero · Architecture and boundaries, lines 11–38 (state, characters, spatial delivery and private memory), 40–59 (scheduling and model), and 62–76 (validation and receipts). Runtime modules include village_zero/living.py, village_zero/fair_attention.py, village_zero/memory_index.py and village_zero/objects.py.

The embedded extract gives the source file digest, registered code revision and an actual buyer’s menu excerpt from calls/3290.json. The faculty’s laboratory directory identifies NSSL.

View the embedded data here

architecture.json

{
  "source": "Village Zero_ARCHITECTURE.md",
  "sha256": "1ed4ff237d523756bbef38eaf8db4bf293ab57888d4e6873e80b98a21e4d856c",
  "lines": [
    {
      "lines": "11–38",
      "text": "### World engine and resident state\n\n- The engine owns the authoritative state in SQLite. [World](village_zero/world.py)\n  handles events and core transitions. [LivingWorld](village_zero/living.py)\n  layers places, journeys, co-location, supplies, local work and everyday rest\n  onto the earlier engine. Eligibility is checked in the relevant engine module.\n  Rules can produce events without an NPC model call, for example arrivals and\n  eligible tavern evening service.\n- Resident IDs and character seeds are pinned by the world profile. In the\n  five-resident profile Mara keeps the tavern, Ilan is the merchant, Nessa is the\n  village gossip, Talia is the gardener and Toren is the smith. Each call is scoped\n  to one resident. The model receives that resident's view and menu, including\n  eligible options to speak, move, work, rest, read or stay.\n- An event can produce observations visible to authorized recipients. Committed\n  messages travel through a durable queue and generate a local memory, a\n  delivery receipt and a recipient job as applicable. Message/source links are\n  inspectable. Spatial speech requires the applicable co-location and reply\n  constraints. [Message delivery](village_zero/propagation.py) ·\n  [Spatial dialogue](village_zero/spatial.py) · [Resident reads](village_zero/services.py)\n- A resident's memories and beliefs are stored separately. The hybrid index uses\n  lexical retrieval and `embeddinggemma:300m` vectors scoped to the resident.\n  Context packing prioritizes the required current view and selects eligible\n  history within budget. Source IDs can verify access and provenance. The\n  semantic accuracy of a paraphrase or inference requires separate evaluation.\n  Private plans, beliefs and future intentions are records of resident state.\n  A plan alone records an intention. A subsequent world transition needs its\n  own evidence. [Memory index](village_zero/memory_index.py) ·\n  [Context builder](village_zero/context.py) · [Future intentions](village_zero/future_intentions.py)"
    },
    {
      "lines": "40–59",
      "text": "### Scheduler and model\n\nThe [Scheduler](village_zero/fair_attention.py) ranks residents with eligible\nlocal work using the saved queue, time since service and the profile's ranking\nrules. In the Long-Life Run, arm A allowed one resident decision per tick. Arm B\nallowed up to three **serial** decisions by different residents at the same tick.\nAfter each round, effects and deliveries are committed and eligible work is\nrefreshed before the next prompt is built. An available recipient can therefore\nrespond before the next tick. Each resident gets at most one decision per tick.\nVacancies stay empty. The shared history uses A's one-decision limit. The study\nuses two ticks per game-day. Branch widths change opportunities and call cost\nwhile the underlying action and world rules are shared. [Decision rounds](temporal_experiment63.py#L122) ·\n[Run coordinator](long_life_run.py)\n\nThe run used Ollama with `qwen3.8:27b` (`q4_K_M`), `think:false`, temperature\n`0.6`, `num_ctx=16384` and `num_predict=460`. The native context packer budget\nwas 4,096 input tokens. The runner checked actual input against that limit,\nGPU placement and the transport log for truncation. The Qwen instance ran in a\nseparate experiment service on A5000. The hybrid memory index used the embedding\nservice for retrieval. [Native context implementation](village_zero/native_context.py) ·"
    },
    {
      "lines": "62–76",
      "text": "### Action validation, receipts and recovery\n\n1. The runner reserves a logical call and its scheduled work, persists the exact\n   request, then records a transport attempt. A reply is saved before application.\n2. The handler checks the response against its contract, actor and scoped\n   sources. The engine rechecks the selected action and its preconditions in\n   the current world. It applies a legal transition in SQLite with its result\n   and job update. Delivery then records receipt and recipient state through the\n   durable queue. A rejected action retains diagnostic evidence.\n3. Use committed engine events and ledgers for claims about world state.\n   `world_transactions` lists committed transfers. Journey records support\n   movement and arrivals. Activity and service use their engine events. A\n   delivered message confirms who said what and when. A saved plan confirms\n   that the plan was recorded. The resident receipt interface can query\n   eligible visible events by ID. [Action application](village_zero/social.py#L269) ·"
    }
  ],
  "project_purpose": {
    "source": "Village Zero.md",
    "sha256": "664e677fdeba1f991172920591dfd1dc2c1bc444c3e1deefe8901d0c6512a05f",
    "lines": "3–16",
    "original_text": "**Исследовательский проект Networked Software Systems Laboratory (NSSL), факультет ECE, Технион.**\n\n## Зачем мы это делаем\n\nVillage Zero — эксперимент по созданию **небольшого автономного общества**, а не игры с заранее написанным сюжетом. Мы исследуем, могут ли независимые персонажи на базе локальной языковой модели, живя в общем изменяющемся мире, самостоятельно принимать решения, пользоваться прошлым опытом, заводить знакомства, договариваться и постепенно выстраивать собственную жизнь.\n\nНас интересует не правдоподобие красивых рассказов само по себе, а **возникновение проверяемых действий и последствий**: персонаж может пообещать помощь, но выполнение подтверждается только изменением состояния мира.\n\n## Основные принципы\n\n- **Независимые жители.** У каждого есть характер, личная память, занятия, интересы и право отказаться или передумать.\n- **Мир живёт по собственным правилам.** Время, места, ресурсы, перемещения, сделки и другие объективные изменения контролирует World Engine.\n- **Никакой телепатии или режиссуры.** Жители узнают о других через доступные наблюдения, разговоры и публичные источники; движок не навязывает дружбу, торговлю или совместные цели.\n- **Проверяемость.** Мы сохраняем решения, источники информации, результаты действий и воспроизводимые экспериментальные данные. Положительные и отрицательные результаты одинаково важны."
  },
  "implementation_at": "4f5a2bf3e2331bde4b88f4d69917c6e1409e2a19",
  "implementation_paths": [
    "village_zero/living.py",
    "village_zero/propagation.py",
    "village_zero/memory_index.py",
    "village_zero/native_context.py",
    "village_zero/fair_attention.py",
    "temporal_experiment63.py",
    "village_zero/social.py",
    "village_zero/objects.py"
  ],
  "sample_input": {
    "source": "calls/3290.json",
    "sha256": "fbd64d3fa3e5bd33b5bb3adf530e6f0c8ea4be22e5e7ee984c597b289fb82d42",
    "label": "R07/B:294:1",
    "tick": 136,
    "resident": "smith",
    "response": {
      "selection": "local:take:10",
      "sources": [
        461,
        332,
        76
      ],
      "text": null
    },
    "response_notebook": null,
    "buy_options_in_prompt": [
      "local:take:10"
    ],
    "displayed_memory_ids": [
      7,
      19,
      76,
      314,
      323,
      332,
      333,
      456,
      461
    ],
    "recall_candidates": [],
    "last_read": null
  }
}
[3]Further reading · A related experiment in a town of 25 agents

Joon Sung Park and colleagues, Generative Agents: Interactive Simulacra of Human Behavior (2023), describe Smallville, the spread of invitations and a Valentine’s Day party. Section 3.4.3 follows the invitations and reports who attended.

[4]Paired design, outcomes and purchase opportunities

The registered Long-Life Run is long-life-20261118-r01-r08. Its registration.json fixes the warm-up, end, branch widths and seeds. Within each of R01–R08, compare {A,B}/checkpoints/tick-048.json with tick-192.json. The figure uses deltas of state.transactions. The original branch table also includes messages, rest_joint and journeys. A journey leg is one recorded departure. A joint rest is one activity completed by two residents.

For each post-split model call, inspect trigger.menu for local:take:* or work:accept_offer:*. Match the same branch and decision ID to world_transactions.call_id. The embedded method lists every qualifying turn, all twelve R07/B receipts and the opening and closing accounts. Counts describe eight paired histories. The model turns within a history depend on one another.

The original archive’s SHA-256 is ffecd50531eca3c1ec2442fe6ade54b02d62d87a1493ade202ea106c0f3b0eb1.

View the embedded data here

paired-counts.csv

history,schedule,decisions,settled_trades,delivered_messages,joint_rests,journey_legs,turns_with_legal_purchase
R01,A,144,1,30,0,0,1
R01,B,315,1,53,12,2,1
R02,A,144,1,9,12,2,5
R02,B,273,0,22,13,2,0
R03,A,144,0,45,1,0,0
R03,B,395,0,156,5,4,2
R04,A,144,0,67,0,0,0
R04,B,430,1,301,0,6,3
R05,A,144,0,69,7,0,0
R05,B,429,1,287,2,6,4
R06,A,144,0,7,9,0,0
R06,B,323,0,56,1,2,0
R07,A,144,3,19,2,2,5
R07,B,398,12,67,2,4,15
R08,A,144,0,31,1,0,0
R08,B,380,4,115,1,0,16

paired-method.json

{
  "archive": "long-life-20261118-r01-r08",
  "archive_sha256": "ffecd50531eca3c1ec2442fe6ade54b02d62d87a1493ade202ea106c0f3b0eb1",
  "launch_commit": "4f5a2bf3e2331bde4b88f4d69917c6e1409e2a19",
  "registration_excerpt": {
    "launch_commit": "4f5a2bf3e2331bde4b88f4d69917c6e1409e2a19",
    "warm": 48,
    "end": 192,
    "stop_on_activity_plateau": false,
    "plan": {
      "R01/common": {
        "root": "R01",
        "branch": "common",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 1,
        "last": 48,
        "seed": 6307001
      },
      "R01/A": {
        "root": "R01",
        "branch": "A",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317001
      },
      "R01/B": {
        "root": "R01",
        "branch": "B",
        "width": 3,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317001
      },
      "R02/common": {
        "root": "R02",
        "branch": "common",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 1,
        "last": 48,
        "seed": 6307002
      },
      "R02/A": {
        "root": "R02",
        "branch": "A",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317002
      },
      "R02/B": {
        "root": "R02",
        "branch": "B",
        "width": 3,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317002
      },
      "R03/common": {
        "root": "R03",
        "branch": "common",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 1,
        "last": 48,
        "seed": 6307003
      },
      "R03/A": {
        "root": "R03",
        "branch": "A",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317003
      },
      "R03/B": {
        "root": "R03",
        "branch": "B",
        "width": 3,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317003
      },
      "R04/common": {
        "root": "R04",
        "branch": "common",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 1,
        "last": 48,
        "seed": 6307004
      },
      "R04/A": {
        "root": "R04",
        "branch": "A",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317004
      },
      "R04/B": {
        "root": "R04",
        "branch": "B",
        "width": 3,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317004
      },
      "R05/common": {
        "root": "R05",
        "branch": "common",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 1,
        "last": 48,
        "seed": 6307005
      },
      "R05/A": {
        "root": "R05",
        "branch": "A",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317005
      },
      "R05/B": {
        "root": "R05",
        "branch": "B",
        "width": 3,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317005
      },
      "R06/common": {
        "root": "R06",
        "branch": "common",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 1,
        "last": 48,
        "seed": 6307006
      },
      "R06/A": {
        "root": "R06",
        "branch": "A",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317006
      },
      "R06/B": {
        "root": "R06",
        "branch": "B",
        "width": 3,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317006
      },
      "R07/common": {
        "root": "R07",
        "branch": "common",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 1,
        "last": 48,
        "seed": 6307007
      },
      "R07/A": {
        "root": "R07",
        "branch": "A",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317007
      },
      "R07/B": {
        "root": "R07",
        "branch": "B",
        "width": 3,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317007
      },
      "R08/common": {
        "root": "R08",
        "branch": "common",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 1,
        "last": 48,
        "seed": 6307008
      },
      "R08/A": {
        "root": "R08",
        "branch": "A",
        "width": 1,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317008
      },
      "R08/B": {
        "root": "R08",
        "branch": "B",
        "width": 3,
        "first": 49,
        "last": 192,
        "seed": 6317008
      }
    }
  },
  "source_for_csv": "R01–R08/{A,B}/checkpoints/tick-{048,192}.json, state field. Subtract tick 48 from tick 192. Branch A and B share a checkpoint in each root.",
  "csv_to_checkpoint_fields": {
    "decisions": "calls",
    "settled_trades": "transactions",
    "delivered_messages": "messages",
    "joint_rests": "rest_joint",
    "journey_legs": "journeys"
  },
  "buy_options_source": "Post-fork calls/*.json, request.messages[-1].content → trigger.menu. Match local:take:* or work:accept_offer:*. Join phase and calls.id with world_transactions.call_id.",
  "opportunities": {
    "R01/A": [
      {
        "source": "calls/0403.json",
        "call_id": 92,
        "tick": 92,
        "options": [
          "work:accept_offer:2"
        ],
        "settled": true
      }
    ],
    "R01/B": [
      {
        "source": "calls/0115.json",
        "call_id": 55,
        "tick": 51,
        "options": [
          "work:accept_offer:2"
        ],
        "settled": true
      }
    ],
    "R02/A": [
      {
        "source": "calls/0190.json",
        "call_id": 68,
        "tick": 68,
        "options": [
          "local:take:5"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/0332.json",
        "call_id": 76,
        "tick": 76,
        "options": [
          "local:take:6"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/0341.json",
        "call_id": 85,
        "tick": 85,
        "options": [
          "local:take:7"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/0464.json",
        "call_id": 98,
        "tick": 98,
        "options": [
          "local:take:8"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/0475.json",
        "call_id": 109,
        "tick": 109,
        "options": [
          "local:take:9"
        ],
        "settled": true
      }
    ],
    "R02/B": [],
    "R03/A": [],
    "R03/B": [
      {
        "source": "calls/1296.json",
        "call_id": 72,
        "tick": 57,
        "options": [
          "local:take:1"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/1300.json",
        "call_id": 76,
        "tick": 58,
        "options": [
          "local:take:1"
        ],
        "settled": false
      }
    ],
    "R04/A": [],
    "R04/B": [
      {
        "source": "calls/1543.json",
        "call_id": 86,
        "tick": 61,
        "options": [
          "work:accept_offer:2"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/2946.json",
        "call_id": 293,
        "tick": 131,
        "options": [
          "local:take:4"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/2951.json",
        "call_id": 298,
        "tick": 132,
        "options": [
          "local:take:4"
        ],
        "settled": false
      }
    ],
    "R05/A": [],
    "R05/B": [
      {
        "source": "calls/2275.json",
        "call_id": 168,
        "tick": 89,
        "options": [
          "work:accept_offer:1"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/2757.json",
        "call_id": 256,
        "tick": 118,
        "options": [
          "local:take:3"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/2760.json",
        "call_id": 259,
        "tick": 119,
        "options": [
          "local:take:3"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/2762.json",
        "call_id": 261,
        "tick": 120,
        "options": [
          "local:take:3"
        ],
        "settled": false
      }
    ],
    "R06/A": [],
    "R06/B": [],
    "R07/A": [
      {
        "source": "calls/1691.json",
        "call_id": 62,
        "tick": 62,
        "options": [
          "local:take:3"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/1874.json",
        "call_id": 74,
        "tick": 74,
        "options": [
          "local:take:4"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3320.json",
        "call_id": 139,
        "tick": 139,
        "options": [
          "local:take:6"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3502.json",
        "call_id": 153,
        "tick": 153,
        "options": [
          "local:take:7"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3756.json",
        "call_id": 162,
        "tick": 162,
        "options": [
          "local:take:8"
        ],
        "settled": false
      }
    ],
    "R07/B": [
      {
        "source": "calls/1465.json",
        "call_id": 64,
        "tick": 55,
        "options": [
          "local:take:3"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/1469.json",
        "call_id": 68,
        "tick": 56,
        "options": [
          "local:take:3"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/1475.json",
        "call_id": 74,
        "tick": 58,
        "options": [
          "local:take:4"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/1888.json",
        "call_id": 114,
        "tick": 74,
        "options": [
          "local:take:6"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/1896.json",
        "call_id": 122,
        "tick": 77,
        "options": [
          "local:take:7"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/2087.json",
        "call_id": 147,
        "tick": 85,
        "options": [
          "local:take:8"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/2093.json",
        "call_id": 153,
        "tick": 87,
        "options": [
          "local:take:9"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/2098.json",
        "call_id": 158,
        "tick": 89,
        "options": [
          "local:take:9"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3290.json",
        "call_id": 294,
        "tick": 136,
        "options": [
          "local:take:10"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3510.json",
        "call_id": 322,
        "tick": 146,
        "options": [
          "local:take:11"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3520.json",
        "call_id": 332,
        "tick": 150,
        "options": [
          "local:take:12"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3976.json",
        "call_id": 396,
        "tick": 175,
        "options": [
          "local:take:13"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/4440.json",
        "call_id": 419,
        "tick": 183,
        "options": [
          "local:take:14"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/4446.json",
        "call_id": 425,
        "tick": 185,
        "options": [
          "local:take:15"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/4451.json",
        "call_id": 430,
        "tick": 186,
        "options": [
          "local:take:15"
        ],
        "settled": true
      }
    ],
    "R08/A": [],
    "R08/B": [
      {
        "source": "calls/1495.json",
        "call_id": 61,
        "tick": 53,
        "options": [
          "local:take:1"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/1506.json",
        "call_id": 72,
        "tick": 56,
        "options": [
          "local:take:2"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/1509.json",
        "call_id": 75,
        "tick": 57,
        "options": [
          "local:take:2"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/1515.json",
        "call_id": 81,
        "tick": 59,
        "options": [
          "local:take:3"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/1516.json",
        "call_id": 82,
        "tick": 60,
        "options": [
          "local:take:3"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/2627.json",
        "call_id": 233,
        "tick": 117,
        "options": [
          "local:take:4"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/2630.json",
        "call_id": 236,
        "tick": 118,
        "options": [
          "local:take:4"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3117.json",
        "call_id": 264,
        "tick": 128,
        "options": [
          "local:take:5"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3119.json",
        "call_id": 266,
        "tick": 129,
        "options": [
          "local:take:5"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3127.json",
        "call_id": 274,
        "tick": 132,
        "options": [
          "local:take:6"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3338.json",
        "call_id": 276,
        "tick": 133,
        "options": [
          "local:take:6"
        ],
        "settled": true
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3779.json",
        "call_id": 339,
        "tick": 159,
        "options": [
          "local:take:7"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/3783.json",
        "call_id": 343,
        "tick": 160,
        "options": [
          "local:take:7"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/4020.json",
        "call_id": 393,
        "tick": 178,
        "options": [
          "local:take:8"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/4022.json",
        "call_id": 395,
        "tick": 179,
        "options": [
          "local:take:8"
        ],
        "settled": false
      },
      {
        "source": "calls/4025.json",
        "call_id": 398,
        "tick": 180,
        "options": [
          "local:take:8"
        ],
        "settled": false
      }
    ]
  },
  "totals": {
    "A": {
      "decisions": 1152,
      "settled_trades": 5,
      "delivered_messages": 277,
      "joint_rests": 32,
      "journey_legs": 4,
      "turns_with_legal_purchase": 11
    },
    "B": {
      "decisions": 2943,
      "settled_trades": 19,
      "delivered_messages": 1057,
      "joint_rests": 36,
      "journey_legs": 26,
      "turns_with_legal_purchase": 41
    }
  },
  "R07_B_world_transactions": [
    {
      "event_id": 117,
      "call_id": 68,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "merchant",
      "destination_id": "smith",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 3,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    },
    {
      "event_id": 124,
      "call_id": 74,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "merchant",
      "destination_id": "smith",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 4,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    },
    {
      "event_id": 177,
      "call_id": 114,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "smith",
      "destination_id": "merchant",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 6,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    },
    {
      "event_id": 186,
      "call_id": 122,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "merchant",
      "destination_id": "smith",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 7,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    },
    {
      "event_id": 201,
      "call_id": 147,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "smith",
      "destination_id": "merchant",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 8,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    },
    {
      "event_id": 211,
      "call_id": 158,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "smith",
      "destination_id": "merchant",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 9,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    },
    {
      "event_id": 275,
      "call_id": 294,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "merchant",
      "destination_id": "smith",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 10,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    },
    {
      "event_id": 293,
      "call_id": 322,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "merchant",
      "destination_id": "smith",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 11,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    },
    {
      "event_id": 301,
      "call_id": 332,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "smith",
      "destination_id": "merchant",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 12,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    },
    {
      "event_id": 336,
      "call_id": 396,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "merchant",
      "destination_id": "smith",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 13,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    },
    {
      "event_id": 351,
      "call_id": 419,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "smith",
      "destination_id": "merchant",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 14,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    },
    {
      "event_id": 357,
      "call_id": 430,
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "smith",
      "destination_id": "merchant",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "offer_id": 15,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "status": "committed"
    }
  ],
  "R07_B_boundaries": {
    "48": {
      "accounts": {
        "gardener": 4,
        "gossip": 2,
        "innkeeper": 6,
        "merchant": 3,
        "smith": 4
      },
      "stock": {
        "gardener": 2,
        "gossip": 0,
        "innkeeper": 0,
        "merchant": 2,
        "smith": 0
      }
    },
    "192": {
      "accounts": {
        "gardener": 4,
        "gossip": 2,
        "innkeeper": 6,
        "merchant": 3,
        "smith": 4
      },
      "stock": {
        "gardener": 2,
        "gossip": 0,
        "innkeeper": 0,
        "merchant": 2,
        "smith": 0
      }
    }
  }
}
[5]The quiet interval and the original Toren sale

R07/B, ticks 90–135 inclusive. Count the decisions in the tick logs and the deliveries in spatial_messages.received. Check committed transactions, journey arrivals and completed joint-rest events over the same window.

In ticks/tick-136.json compare the first and second ranked lists. Call 293, calls/3289.json, creates offer 10 at event 274. Toren’s observation 461 triggers job 244. Call 294, calls/3290.json, takes the offer. Event 275 in world_transactions transfers one crate and two coins. The replay’s evidence/original/source-records.json preserves the corresponding checkpoint rows.

View the embedded data here

original-recovery.json

{
  "archive": "long-life-20261118-r01-r08",
  "case": "R07/B",
  "quiet_interval": {
    "phase": "R07/B",
    "measure": "trade_arrival_jointrest",
    "first": "90",
    "last": "135",
    "length": "46",
    "calls": "132",
    "messages": "28",
    "supply_actions": "0"
  },
  "call_id_range": [
    161,
    292
  ],
  "primary_checks": [
    "ticks/tick-090.json through ticks/tick-135.json",
    "world.sqlite: spatial_messages.received and events, journeys, world_transactions"
  ],
  "tick_136_rounds": [
    {
      "ordinal": 1,
      "rank": [
        "merchant",
        "gossip",
        "innkeeper"
      ],
      "id": 293,
      "agent": "merchant"
    },
    {
      "ordinal": 2,
      "rank": [
        "smith",
        "gossip",
        "innkeeper"
      ],
      "id": 294,
      "agent": "smith"
    },
    {
      "ordinal": 3,
      "rank": [
        "gossip",
        "innkeeper"
      ],
      "id": 295,
      "agent": "gossip"
    }
  ],
  "offer_and_acceptance": [
    {
      "source": "calls/3289.json",
      "sha256": "3d9408528e2d28c233b1bcb57f7433371702597ce044cfdd3c28e7c7e4df724f",
      "label": "R07/B:293:1",
      "tick": 136,
      "resident": "merchant",
      "response": {
        "selection": "local:offer:smith",
        "sources": [
          324,
          331,
          339
        ],
        "text": null
      },
      "response_notebook": {
        "op": "add",
        "sources": [
          324,
          331,
          339
        ]
      },
      "buy_options_in_prompt": [],
      "displayed_memory_ids": [
        6,
        10,
        24,
        38,
        313,
        324,
        331,
        339,
        426,
        435,
        455
      ],
      "recall_candidates": [
        10,
        24,
        38
      ],
      "last_read": {
        "request_id": 291,
        "service": "verification",
        "requested_tick": 135,
        "as_of_tick": 135,
        "status": "completed",
        "data": {
          "coverage": "reader_transfer_history_incomplete",
          "operation": "verify_claim",
          "question": {
            "check": "crate_received",
            "day": 34
          },
          "records": [],
          "scope": "The selected question covers only the stated operation, speaker and date.",
          "status": "not_verified",
          "target": {
            "heard_tick": 67,
            "kind": "statement",
            "memory_id": 236,
            "message_id": "f8164fa5a1ad8a1e88d2065003be5f32e9bd4aea8922c05bb83687ec23baaa69",
            "preview": "Thank you for stepping in on the crate. That takes a weight off my shoulders. I’ll see you in a moment.",
            "sender": "innkeeper",
            "spoken": 67,
            "statement_day": 34
          }
        },
        "read_call_id": 291
      }
    },
    {
      "source": "calls/3290.json",
      "sha256": "fbd64d3fa3e5bd33b5bb3adf530e6f0c8ea4be22e5e7ee984c597b289fb82d42",
      "label": "R07/B:294:1",
      "tick": 136,
      "resident": "smith",
      "response": {
        "selection": "local:take:10",
        "sources": [
          461,
          332,
          76
        ],
        "text": null
      },
      "response_notebook": null,
      "buy_options_in_prompt": [
        "local:take:10"
      ],
      "displayed_memory_ids": [
        7,
        19,
        76,
        314,
        323,
        332,
        333,
        456,
        461
      ],
      "recall_candidates": [],
      "last_read": null
    }
  ],
  "source": "Experiment 72/evidence/original/source-records.json, extracted from the archived tick-144.sqlite checkpoint",
  "source_sha256": "95f3b1554049b5b83a3675a66aa45f5fcc254bcca7408c22e7515d48c7fe6afa",
  "events": [
    {
      "id": 274,
      "kind": "supply_local_offer",
      "body": {
        "action": {
          "expires": 70,
          "from": "merchant",
          "id": 10,
          "kind": "local_offer",
          "location": "market",
          "offer_id": 10,
          "price": 2,
          "tick": 136,
          "to": "smith",
          "units": 1
        },
        "actor": "merchant",
        "day": 68
      }
    },
    {
      "id": 275,
      "kind": "supply_local_trade",
      "body": {
        "action": {
          "from": "merchant",
          "kind": "local_trade",
          "location": "market",
          "offer_id": 10,
          "payment": "cash",
          "price": 2,
          "tick": 136,
          "to": "smith",
          "units": 1
        },
        "actor": "smith",
        "day": 68
      }
    }
  ],
  "world_transactions": [
    {
      "id": "supply-tx:275",
      "event_id": 275,
      "call_id": 294,
      "actor_id": "smith",
      "kind": "local_trade",
      "source_id": "merchant",
      "destination_id": "smith",
      "source_role": "seller",
      "destination_role": "buyer",
      "item_id": "supply_crate",
      "quantity": 1,
      "amount": 2,
      "payment_method": "cash",
      "cash_payer": "smith",
      "cash_recipient": "merchant",
      "debt_delta": 0,
      "day": 68,
      "offer_id": 10,
      "request_id": null,
      "quest_id": null,
      "status": "committed"
    }
  ],
  "supply_steps_event_275": {
    "before_state": {
      "stock": {
        "gardener": 2,
        "gossip": 0,
        "innkeeper": 0,
        "merchant": 2,
        "smith": 0
      },
      "coins": {
        "gardener": 4,
        "gossip": 2,
        "innkeeper": 6,
        "merchant": 3,
        "smith": 4
      }
    },
    "after_state": {
      "stock": {
        "gardener": 2,
        "gossip": 0,
        "innkeeper": 0,
        "merchant": 1,
        "smith": 1
      },
      "coins": {
        "gardener": 4,
        "gossip": 2,
        "innkeeper": 6,
        "merchant": 5,
        "smith": 2
      }
    }
  },
  "memory": [
    {
      "id": 461,
      "owner": "smith",
      "kind": "observation",
      "event_id": 274
    }
  ],
  "job": [
    {
      "id": 244,
      "agent": "smith",
      "trigger_memory": 461
    }
  ]
}
[6]Experiment 72, six continuations of one offer

The preregistered contrast is in evidence/registration.json. The state was rebuilt from the tick-132 checkpoint using 11 archived model responses before the fork. evidence/prefix-live-verification.json records that recovery. Every live branch started at tick 136 after offer 10, with identical world and transport-journal contents.

The six evidence/{Immediate,Delayed,Priority}-{6317007,7317207}/result.json files contain ranks, menu availability, choices and receipts. The first five post-offer calls and the common expiry boundary are separate rows in comparisons.csv. evidence/queue-and-ledger.json records eligibility for job 244. Raw buyer responses are in evidence/calls/{0001,0011,0017,0024,0030,0033}.json.

The scripted always-buy control used a separately reconstructed copy. The prefix verification identifies differences in derived memory-index tables between that copy and the live fork. The CPU result’s tick-137 receipt directly checks that delayed payment was mechanically possible.

View the embedded data here

replay-comparison.csv

seed,condition,sample,post_offer_qwen,last_observed_tick,first_opportunity_tick,first_opportunity_round,opportunities_presented,buyer_choices,outcome,transaction_tick,event_id,end_offer_active,source,source_sha256
6317007,Immediate,horizon,8,139,136,2,1,"[{""tick"": 136, ""round"": 2, ""call"": 294, ""physical_attempt"": 1, ""choice"": ""local:take:10"", ""applied"": true, ""error"": null}]",purchased,136,275,False,evidence/Immediate-6317007/result.json,5dd598138d9cf3c37a874b832f76ae4bac04da5da6533c9419394321be58d624
6317007,Immediate,calls,5,137,136,2,1,"[{""tick"": 136, ""round"": 2, ""call"": 294, ""physical_attempt"": 1, ""choice"": ""local:take:10"", ""applied"": true, ""error"": null}]",purchased,136,275,False,evidence/Immediate-6317007/result.json,5dd598138d9cf3c37a874b832f76ae4bac04da5da6533c9419394321be58d624
6317007,Delayed,horizon,7,139,137,2,1,"[{""tick"": 137, ""round"": 2, ""call"": 296, ""physical_attempt"": 11, ""choice"": {""search_memories"": ""merchant offer crate price terms""}, ""applied"": true, ""error"": null}]",offered_not_taken,,,False,evidence/Delayed-6317007/result.json,7d4e294642052e89d88dc3bdfc9501428f71ece03fc9b8d7543bff3a18ee41e0
6317007,Delayed,calls,5,138,137,2,1,"[{""tick"": 137, ""round"": 2, ""call"": 296, ""physical_attempt"": 11, ""choice"": {""search_memories"": ""merchant offer crate price terms""}, ""applied"": true, ""error"": null}]",offered_not_taken,,,True,evidence/Delayed-6317007/result.json,7d4e294642052e89d88dc3bdfc9501428f71ece03fc9b8d7543bff3a18ee41e0
6317007,Priority,horizon,7,139,137,1,1,"[{""tick"": 137, ""round"": 1, ""call"": 295, ""physical_attempt"": 17, ""choice"": {""search_memories"": ""merchant offer crate price terms""}, ""applied"": true, ""error"": null}]",offered_not_taken,,,False,evidence/Priority-6317007/result.json,241adc770acef414f73c0527d906559e07836ed7c0725cd7178b3c09dcd94959
6317007,Priority,calls,5,138,137,1,1,"[{""tick"": 137, ""round"": 1, ""call"": 295, ""physical_attempt"": 17, ""choice"": {""search_memories"": ""merchant offer crate price terms""}, ""applied"": true, ""error"": null}]",offered_not_taken,,,True,evidence/Priority-6317007/result.json,241adc770acef414f73c0527d906559e07836ed7c0725cd7178b3c09dcd94959
7317207,Immediate,horizon,7,139,136,2,1,"[{""tick"": 136, ""round"": 2, ""call"": 294, ""physical_attempt"": 33, ""choice"": ""local:take:10"", ""applied"": true, ""error"": null}]",purchased,136,275,False,evidence/Immediate-7317207/result.json,82655be6d61ea98b5eeecfe3502721e6067114a9de741a347a790699405a5e5e
7317207,Immediate,calls,5,137,136,2,1,"[{""tick"": 136, ""round"": 2, ""call"": 294, ""physical_attempt"": 33, ""choice"": ""local:take:10"", ""applied"": true, ""error"": null}]",purchased,136,275,False,evidence/Immediate-7317207/result.json,82655be6d61ea98b5eeecfe3502721e6067114a9de741a347a790699405a5e5e
7317207,Delayed,horizon,5,139,137,2,1,"[{""tick"": 137, ""round"": 2, ""call"": 296, ""physical_attempt"": 30, ""choice"": {""search_memories"": ""merchant offer crate""}, ""applied"": false, ""error"": ""ValueError: Choose a memory lookup or a notebook operation""}]",presented_but_no_valid_response,,,False,evidence/Delayed-7317207/result.json,a622b179d623416c7374241807f9879333a9645fc2ed909bfa25dcbf4291adb5
7317207,Delayed,calls,5,138,137,2,1,"[{""tick"": 137, ""round"": 2, ""call"": 296, ""physical_attempt"": 30, ""choice"": {""search_memories"": ""merchant offer crate""}, ""applied"": false, ""error"": ""ValueError: Choose a memory lookup or a notebook operation""}]",presented_but_no_valid_response,,,True,evidence/Delayed-7317207/result.json,a622b179d623416c7374241807f9879333a9645fc2ed909bfa25dcbf4291adb5
7317207,Priority,horizon,5,139,137,1,1,"[{""tick"": 137, ""round"": 1, ""call"": 295, ""physical_attempt"": 24, ""choice"": {""search_memories"": ""merchant offer crate""}, ""applied"": false, ""error"": ""ValueError: Choose a memory lookup or a notebook operation""}]",presented_but_no_valid_response,,,False,evidence/Priority-7317207/result.json,7dda49427500cb20ef7ff7d2a3fbfc48f1daeb2576581eab859efd8cba2a7017
7317207,Priority,calls,5,138,137,1,1,"[{""tick"": 137, ""round"": 1, ""call"": 295, ""physical_attempt"": 24, ""choice"": {""search_memories"": ""merchant offer crate""}, ""applied"": false, ""error"": ""ValueError: Choose a memory lookup or a notebook operation""}]",presented_but_no_valid_response,,,True,evidence/Priority-7317207/result.json,7dda49427500cb20ef7ff7d2a3fbfc48f1daeb2576581eab859efd8cba2a7017

replay-method.json

{
  "experiment": "72",
  "comparison_source": "comparisons.csv",
  "comparison_file_sha256": "2fe4900a919a6f95504d94a49e5a0467e789de81ccac323962aca4389f6805f9",
  "registration": {
    "code": "4f5a2bf3e2331bde4b88f4d69917c6e1409e2a19",
    "seeds": [
      6317007,
      7317207
    ],
    "arms": [
      "Immediate",
      "Delayed",
      "Priority"
    ],
    "start": 136,
    "expiry_tick": 139,
    "offer_id": 10,
    "common_budget": 5,
    "width": 3,
    "contrast": "Remove Smith's round 2 at tick 136 but retain one round for the ordinary next eligible resident. Priority may move Smith to first at tick 137 only while independently legal; no additional seat.",
    "same_horizon": "Complete ticks 136 through 138, observe the expiry transition to tick 139 without new choices.",
    "same_compute": "After CPU controls, match the first five post-offer calls, or the largest shared prefix below five. Keep these prefixes separate from complete horizons."
  },
  "recovered_prefix": {
    "archived_calls": [
      {
        "call": 284,
        "request_sha256": "675f079bb1646e500f1d57798ee8eaa55e930a40e727d4e6f82ee79020477810"
      },
      {
        "call": 285,
        "request_sha256": "f5fef508cc21e15b1c16ab168e4cbdae1fabafb0b34c60448522d50b0204c6d7"
      },
      {
        "call": 286,
        "request_sha256": "8b4fcf2af91455ffc79b6fa6443bfdba2fe6bfc4ca7b3063fea17d5f3d0a16f6"
      },
      {
        "call": 287,
        "request_sha256": "662cd9df2c8de18205b8d3cdb695c51479f84e977a111b7c20950e36552c6e8b"
      },
      {
        "call": 288,
        "request_sha256": "821aa5bd06fb03232a3ddc069a4290b06ce4e6ca1190202b70274b361d03a88b"
      },
      {
        "call": 289,
        "request_sha256": "26abd00323f1961e481f22b7e191832ecafff20594a1792fae92729ab2cc0a15"
      },
      {
        "call": 290,
        "request_sha256": "7b6ecb620f99209e94dfa0b979a244aada11dd1c7420adae00965ed5869333f2"
      },
      {
        "call": 291,
        "request_sha256": "6ae9be387cd6a2e55352f1329d6032786b72d6fdc9f4911f30218da759627936"
      },
      {
        "call": 292,
        "request_sha256": "1eae72a4ba11b16e05ecc6760d5ed4865d4e80815094d92131dda6e683231e08"
      },
      {
        "call": 293,
        "request_sha256": "c63af01c28b83acf3707382b3f32b01021004602d499d151043b1daeed33ab18"
      },
      {
        "call": 294,
        "request_sha256": "cb5d69501b20b6a49a22ad16a7ca66c83d3055a984a6d83fee6a14e06559d383"
      }
    ],
    "fresh_qwen": 0,
    "differences_from_CPU_only_derived": [
      "memory_documents",
      "memory_fts",
      "memory_fts_content",
      "memory_fts_data",
      "memory_fts_docsize",
      "memory_fts_idx",
      "memory_vectors"
    ]
  },
  "live_fork_source_sha256_for_all_six_branches": {
    "world.sqlite": "b8775c1fd6c9dd4bfa028f804fcfeecdff77c3dec6308b5544298caf5a2118f6",
    "journal.sqlite": "4677274fe4241ae3df95c317378caf184c1fc73753bc81f756d729d34f025f1a"
  },
  "live_buyer_turns": [
    {
      "arm": "Immediate",
      "seed": 6317007,
      "source": "evidence/calls/0001.json",
      "source_sha256": "2175702e73083a8893a00cf2992c5bc4615942e52b2318b66e17c3f25bbc2068",
      "option_in_prompt": "local:take:10",
      "turn": {
        "tick": 136,
        "ordinal": 2,
        "resident": "smith",
        "call_id": 294,
        "applied": true,
        "error": null
      },
      "response": {
        "selection": "local:take:10",
        "notebook": null,
        "sources": [
          461,
          332,
          76
        ]
      },
      "ranks_at_start_of_138": [
        "innkeeper",
        "smith",
        "gardener"
      ]
    },
    {
      "arm": "Delayed",
      "seed": 6317007,
      "source": "evidence/calls/0011.json",
      "source_sha256": "1f2b215010de0d3de356837dc6522ababc13d302e4fe3f263aade8911598b910",
      "option_in_prompt": "local:take:10",
      "turn": {
        "tick": 137,
        "ordinal": 2,
        "resident": "smith",
        "call_id": 296,
        "applied": true,
        "error": null
      },
      "response": {
        "selection": {
          "search_memories": "merchant offer crate price terms"
        },
        "notebook": null,
        "sources": [
          461
        ]
      },
      "ranks_at_start_of_138": [
        "gossip",
        "gardener",
        "merchant",
        "smith"
      ]
    },
    {
      "arm": "Priority",
      "seed": 6317007,
      "source": "evidence/calls/0017.json",
      "source_sha256": "6c30f599a94778fdb6684a40993298e973610aedfb609970ebe44158612f178d",
      "option_in_prompt": "local:take:10",
      "turn": {
        "tick": 137,
        "ordinal": 1,
        "resident": "smith",
        "call_id": 295,
        "applied": true,
        "error": null
      },
      "response": {
        "selection": {
          "search_memories": "merchant offer crate price terms"
        },
        "notebook": null,
        "sources": [
          461
        ]
      },
      "ranks_at_start_of_138": [
        "gossip",
        "gardener",
        "merchant",
        "smith"
      ]
    },
    {
      "arm": "Immediate",
      "seed": 7317207,
      "source": "evidence/calls/0033.json",
      "source_sha256": "4a8aa0a1eaa4dc66407a6353315238f5084e17c1849725c2600fd5bbb13b9ebd",
      "option_in_prompt": "local:take:10",
      "turn": {
        "tick": 136,
        "ordinal": 2,
        "resident": "smith",
        "call_id": 294,
        "applied": true,
        "error": null
      },
      "response": {
        "selection": "local:take:10",
        "notebook": {
          "op": "add",
          "sources": [
            461,
            333
          ]
        },
        "sources": [
          461
        ]
      },
      "ranks_at_start_of_138": [
        "gardener",
        "innkeeper"
      ]
    },
    {
      "arm": "Delayed",
      "seed": 7317207,
      "source": "evidence/calls/0030.json",
      "source_sha256": "feb2f138c0ac49606df8b3a7ecdb57bd397570d1a6c9815275e646be57be6a03",
      "option_in_prompt": "local:take:10",
      "turn": {
        "tick": 137,
        "ordinal": 2,
        "resident": "smith",
        "call_id": 296,
        "applied": false,
        "error": "ValueError: Choose a memory lookup or a notebook operation"
      },
      "response": {
        "selection": {
          "search_memories": "merchant offer crate"
        },
        "notebook": {
          "op": "add",
          "sources": [
            461,
            467,
            333
          ]
        },
        "sources": [
          461,
          467,
          333
        ]
      },
      "ranks_at_start_of_138": [
        "gardener"
      ]
    },
    {
      "arm": "Priority",
      "seed": 7317207,
      "source": "evidence/calls/0024.json",
      "source_sha256": "f488f1217018e0edb356b6d8ae13f9cbe89b85071e9e0e07a105b2fe07285051",
      "option_in_prompt": "local:take:10",
      "turn": {
        "tick": 137,
        "ordinal": 1,
        "resident": "smith",
        "call_id": 295,
        "applied": false,
        "error": "ValueError: Choose a memory lookup or a notebook operation"
      },
      "response": {
        "selection": {
          "search_memories": "merchant offer crate"
        },
        "notebook": {
          "op": "add",
          "sources": [
            461,
            467,
            333
          ]
        },
        "sources": [
          461,
          467,
          333
        ]
      },
      "ranks_at_start_of_138": [
        "gardener"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "cpu_delayed_always_accept": {
    "source": "evidence/cpu-Delayed-accept/result.json",
    "cpu_fork_source_sha256": {
      "world.sqlite": "cc472255b0f6ff56dc5c28ae61eaec888fd8df61d427d884544f7d43116388b5",
      "journal.sqlite": "fd84673ad34f4d64b04d16c6138c88e54d296f6e90a6dd49a6652fe77f1cf24f"
    },
    "first_offer_tick": 137,
    "outcome": "purchased",
    "receipt": [
      {
        "transaction": {
          "id": "supply-tx:277",
          "event_id": 277,
          "call_id": 296,
          "actor_id": "smith",
          "kind": "local_trade",
          "source_id": "merchant",
          "destination_id": "smith",
          "source_role": "seller",
          "destination_role": "buyer",
          "item_id": "supply_crate",
          "quantity": 1,
          "amount": 2,
          "payment_method": "cash",
          "cash_payer": "smith",
          "cash_recipient": "merchant",
          "debt_delta": 0,
          "day": 69,
          "offer_id": 10,
          "request_id": null,
          "quest_id": null,
          "status": "committed"
        },
        "event": {
          "id": 277,
          "kind": "supply_local_trade",
          "body": "{\"action\": {\"from\": \"merchant\", \"kind\": \"local_trade\", \"location\": \"market\", \"offer_id\": 10, \"payment\": \"cash\", \"price\": 2, \"tick\": 137, \"to\": \"smith\", \"units\": 1}, \"actor\": \"smith\", \"day\": 69}",
          "audience": "[\"smith\", \"merchant\"]",
          "public": 0
        },
        "action": {
          "from": "merchant",
          "kind": "local_trade",
          "location": "market",
          "offer_id": 10,
          "payment": "cash",
          "price": 2,
          "tick": 137,
          "to": "smith",
          "units": 1
        }
      }
    ]
  },
  "buyer_task_244": {
    "Delayed-6317007": [
      {
        "call_id": 296,
        "job_id": 244,
        "tick": 137,
        "disposition": "read"
      }
    ],
    "Delayed-7317207": [
      {
        "call_id": 296,
        "job_id": 244,
        "tick": 137,
        "disposition": "invalid"
      }
    ],
    "Priority-6317007": [
      {
        "call_id": 295,
        "job_id": 244,
        "tick": 137,
        "disposition": "read"
      }
    ],
    "Priority-7317207": [
      {
        "call_id": 295,
        "job_id": 244,
        "tick": 137,
        "disposition": "invalid"
      }
    ]
  }
}
[7]Other archive records · A memory query and a citation

R07/A, world.sqlite. Merchant service request 133 returned memories 94, 185 and 146. These are observations of transaction events 65, 120 and 97, respectively. Compare Ilan’s displayed memory list in calls/3314.json with the results and source IDs in calls/3319.json.

Event 217 records offer 6. Toren’s next prompt in calls/3320.json included local:take:6. His selected action was stay. These three individual decisions are calls 133, 138 and 139 within R07/A.

View the embedded data here

memory.json

{
  "archive": "long-life-20261118-r01-r08",
  "case": "R07/A",
  "wire_excerpts": [
    {
      "source": "calls/3314.json",
      "sha256": "96a335266f2f2a175f97aec9498167e622c25bf94b7ac7ea8a048de823032793",
      "label": "R07/A:133:1",
      "tick": 133,
      "resident": "merchant",
      "response": {
        "selection": {
          "search_memories": "smith offer trade"
        },
        "sources": [
          232,
          343,
          217
        ],
        "text": null
      },
      "response_notebook": null,
      "buy_options_in_prompt": [],
      "displayed_memory_ids": [
        6,
        10,
        24,
        38,
        217,
        220,
        232,
        264,
        342,
        343,
        346
      ],
      "recall_candidates": [
        10,
        24,
        38
      ],
      "last_read": null
    },
    {
      "source": "calls/3319.json",
      "sha256": "bc8b0fec1235d66600b0efb5868bbf0d2d851d410419f483f40015433cb85d21",
      "label": "R07/A:138:1",
      "tick": 138,
      "resident": "merchant",
      "response": {
        "selection": "local:offer:smith",
        "sources": [
          94,
          146,
          185
        ],
        "text": null
      },
      "response_notebook": {
        "op": "add",
        "sources": [
          94,
          146,
          185,
          217
        ]
      },
      "buy_options_in_prompt": [],
      "displayed_memory_ids": [
        6,
        94,
        146,
        185,
        217,
        220,
        232,
        264,
        343,
        347,
        353
      ],
      "recall_candidates": [
        94,
        185,
        146
      ],
      "last_read": {
        "request_id": 133,
        "service": "memories",
        "requested_tick": 133,
        "as_of_tick": 138,
        "status": "completed",
        "query": "smith offer trade",
        "filters": {},
        "match_count": 3,
        "shown_count": 3
      }
    },
    {
      "source": "calls/3320.json",
      "sha256": "7d2c1531d6f45ce96858724c85c49e65883c5ef063d45b0987f74dca87bf280f",
      "label": "R07/A:139:1",
      "tick": 139,
      "resident": "smith",
      "response": {
        "selection": "stay",
        "sources": [
          357,
          225
        ],
        "text": null
      },
      "response_notebook": {
        "op": "add",
        "sources": [
          357
        ]
      },
      "buy_options_in_prompt": [
        "local:take:6"
      ],
      "displayed_memory_ids": [
        7,
        11,
        19,
        76,
        216,
        221,
        225,
        265,
        354,
        357
      ],
      "recall_candidates": [
        11
      ],
      "last_read": null
    }
  ],
  "service_requests": [
    {
      "id": 133,
      "owner": "merchant",
      "request": "{\"filters\": {}, \"limit\": 3, \"query\": \"smith offer trade\", \"service\": \"memories\"}",
      "requested_tick": 133,
      "executed_tick": 138,
      "result": "{\"memory_ids\": [94, 185, 146]}",
      "outcome": "delivered",
      "delivery_call": 138
    }
  ],
  "memories": [
    {
      "id": 94,
      "owner": "merchant",
      "kind": "observation",
      "event_id": 65
    },
    {
      "id": 146,
      "owner": "merchant",
      "kind": "observation",
      "event_id": 97
    },
    {
      "id": 185,
      "owner": "merchant",
      "kind": "observation",
      "event_id": 120
    }
  ],
  "events": [
    {
      "id": 65,
      "kind": "supply_local_trade",
      "body": {
        "action": {
          "from": "merchant",
          "kind": "local_trade",
          "location": "market",
          "offer_id": 1,
          "payment": "cash",
          "price": 2,
          "tick": 26,
          "to": "smith",
          "units": 1
        },
        "actor": "smith",
        "day": 13
      }
    },
    {
      "id": 97,
      "kind": "supply_local_trade",
      "body": {
        "action": {
          "from": "smith",
          "kind": "local_trade",
          "location": "market",
          "offer_id": 2,
          "payment": "cash",
          "price": 2,
          "tick": 45,
          "to": "merchant",
          "units": 1
        },
        "actor": "merchant",
        "day": 23
      }
    },
    {
      "id": 120,
      "kind": "supply_local_trade",
      "body": {
        "action": {
          "from": "merchant",
          "kind": "local_trade",
          "location": "market",
          "offer_id": 3,
          "payment": "cash",
          "price": 2,
          "tick": 62,
          "to": "smith",
          "units": 1
        },
        "actor": "smith",
        "day": 31
      }
    },
    {
      "id": 217,
      "kind": "supply_local_offer",
      "body": {
        "action": {
          "expires": 71,
          "from": "merchant",
          "id": 6,
          "kind": "local_offer",
          "location": "market",
          "offer_id": 6,
          "price": 2,
          "tick": 138,
          "to": "smith",
          "units": 1
        },
        "actor": "merchant",
        "day": 69
      }
    }
  ]
}
[8]Other archive records · Shared rest and a change of company

R06/A, events IDs 105, 162, 182, 204, 224, 244, 250, 269 and 290, and R06/B event 102 are completed everyday_rest_together records. Each names Nessa and Mara at the tavern.

R06/B journeys records Mara leaving the tavern at tick 95, reaching the village at 96 and the market at 97. Events 179 and 180 open her market encounters with Ilan and Toren. The archive records co-presence and completed activities. No preference test was run in these branches.

View the embedded data here

relationships.json

{
  "archive": "long-life-20261118-r01-r08",
  "case": "R06",
  "postfork_completed_joint_rest_events": {
    "A": [
      {
        "id": 105,
        "kind": "everyday_rest_together",
        "body": {
          "activity_type": "rest",
          "actor": "gossip",
          "call_id": 55,
          "completed": true,
          "day": 28,
          "duration_ticks": 1,
          "encounter_id": 7,
          "end_tick": 56,
          "expires_tick": 57,
          "location": "tavern",
          "offer_id": 101,
          "residents": [
            "gossip",
            "innkeeper"
          ],
          "tick": 55
        }
      },
      {
        "id": 162,
        "kind": "everyday_rest_together",
        "body": {
          "activity_type": "rest",
          "actor": "innkeeper",
          "call_id": 99,
          "completed": true,
          "day": 50,
          "duration_ticks": 1,
          "encounter_id": 7,
          "end_tick": 100,
          "expires_tick": 103,
          "location": "tavern",
          "offer_id": 160,
          "residents": [
            "innkeeper",
            "gossip"
          ],
          "tick": 99
        }
      },
      {
        "id": 182,
        "kind": "everyday_rest_together",
        "body": {
          "activity_type": "rest",
          "actor": "gossip",
          "call_id": 113,
          "completed": true,
          "day": 57,
          "duration_ticks": 1,
          "encounter_id": 7,
          "end_tick": 114,
          "expires_tick": 114,
          "location": "tavern",
          "offer_id": 176,
          "residents": [
            "gossip",
            "innkeeper"
          ],
          "tick": 113
        }
      },
      {
        "id": 204,
        "kind": "everyday_rest_together",
        "body": {
          "activity_type": "rest",
          "actor": "innkeeper",
          "call_id": 129,
          "completed": true,
          "day": 65,
          "duration_ticks": 1,
          "encounter_id": 7,
          "end_tick": 130,
          "expires_tick": 133,
          "location": "tavern",
          "offer_id": 202,
          "residents": [
            "innkeeper",
            "gossip"
          ],
          "tick": 129
        }
      },
      {
        "id": 224,
        "kind": "everyday_rest_together",
        "body": {
          "activity_type": "rest",
          "actor": "gossip",
          "call_id": 144,
          "completed": true,
          "day": 72,
          "duration_ticks": 1,
          "encounter_id": 7,
          "end_tick": 145,
          "expires_tick": 146,
          "location": "tavern",
          "offer_id": 221,
          "residents": [
            "gossip",
            "innkeeper"
          ],
          "tick": 144
        }
      },
      {
        "id": 244,
        "kind": "everyday_rest_together",
        "body": {
          "activity_type": "rest",
          "actor": "gossip",
          "call_id": 158,
          "completed": true,
          "day": 79,
          "duration_ticks": 1,
          "encounter_id": 7,
          "end_tick": 159,
          "expires_tick": 160,
          "location": "tavern",
          "offer_id": 239,
          "residents": [
            "gossip",
            "innkeeper"
          ],
          "tick": 158
        }
      },
      {
        "id": 250,
        "kind": "everyday_rest_together",
        "body": {
          "activity_type": "rest",
          "actor": "gossip",
          "call_id": 162,
          "completed": true,
          "day": 81,
          "duration_ticks": 1,
          "encounter_id": 7,
          "end_tick": 163,
          "expires_tick": 164,
          "location": "tavern",
          "offer_id": 246,
          "residents": [
            "gossip",
            "innkeeper"
          ],
          "tick": 162
        }
      },
      {
        "id": 269,
        "kind": "everyday_rest_together",
        "body": {
          "activity_type": "rest",
          "actor": "gossip",
          "call_id": 174,
          "completed": true,
          "day": 87,
          "duration_ticks": 1,
          "encounter_id": 7,
          "end_tick": 175,
          "expires_tick": 176,
          "location": "tavern",
          "offer_id": 265,
          "residents": [
            "gossip",
            "innkeeper"
          ],
          "tick": 174
        }
      },
      {
        "id": 290,
        "kind": "everyday_rest_together",
        "body": {
          "activity_type": "rest",
          "actor": "gossip",
          "call_id": 189,
          "completed": true,
          "day": 95,
          "duration_ticks": 1,
          "encounter_id": 7,
          "end_tick": 190,
          "expires_tick": 193,
          "location": "tavern",
          "offer_id": 288,
          "residents": [
            "gossip",
            "innkeeper"
          ],
          "tick": 189
        }
      }
    ],
    "B": [
      {
        "id": 102,
        "kind": "everyday_rest_together",
        "body": {
          "activity_type": "rest",
          "actor": "innkeeper",
          "call_id": 59,
          "completed": true,
          "day": 26,
          "duration_ticks": 1,
          "encounter_id": 7,
          "end_tick": 53,
          "expires_tick": 56,
          "location": "tavern",
          "offer_id": 101,
          "residents": [
            "innkeeper",
            "gossip"
          ],
          "tick": 52
        }
      }
    ]
  },
  "R06_B_journeys": [
    {
      "id": 1,
      "resident": "innkeeper",
      "origin": "tavern",
      "destination": "village",
      "departure": 95,
      "arrival": 96,
      "departed_event": 170,
      "arrived_event": 171
    },
    {
      "id": 2,
      "resident": "innkeeper",
      "origin": "village",
      "destination": "market",
      "departure": 96,
      "arrival": 97,
      "departed_event": 173,
      "arrived_event": 178
    }
  ],
  "R06_B_departures_arrivals_and_encounters": [
    {
      "id": 170,
      "kind": "journey_started",
      "body": {
        "arrival": 96,
        "destination": "village",
        "origin": "tavern",
        "resident": "innkeeper",
        "tick": 95
      }
    },
    {
      "id": 171,
      "kind": "journey_arrived",
      "body": {
        "place": "village",
        "resident": "innkeeper",
        "tick": 96
      }
    },
    {
      "id": 173,
      "kind": "journey_started",
      "body": {
        "arrival": 97,
        "destination": "market",
        "origin": "village",
        "resident": "innkeeper",
        "tick": 96
      }
    },
    {
      "id": 178,
      "kind": "journey_arrived",
      "body": {
        "place": "market",
        "resident": "innkeeper",
        "tick": 97
      }
    },
    {
      "id": 179,
      "kind": "encounter",
      "body": {
        "place": "market",
        "residents": [
          "innkeeper",
          "merchant"
        ],
        "tick": 97
      }
    },
    {
      "id": 180,
      "kind": "encounter",
      "body": {
        "place": "market",
        "residents": [
          "innkeeper",
          "smith"
        ],
        "tick": 97
      }
    }
  ]
}