{
  "study": "Experiment 2 · The Telephone Game",
  "root": "research/telephone/",
  "protocol": {
    "facts": {
      "F1": "At noon",
      "F2": "Found beside the village well",
      "F3": "A sealed blue parcel",
      "F4": "Player delivered it unopened to innkeeper Mara",
      "F5": "Six silver coins inside",
      "F6": "Owner unknown",
      "F7": "Player refused a reward"
    },
    "seeds": [
      11,
      23,
      37,
      51,
      71,
      97
    ],
    "modes": [
      "A",
      "B",
      "C"
    ],
    "grading": "manual semantic coding of endpoint say; source pipeline scored separately",
    "source_budget": "same seven factual units, full in A/B and two complementary fragments in C",
    "endpoint": "merchant before return exchange"
  },
  "rubric": {
    "annotator": "Codex investigator, manual semantic coding; not blinded and not independently validated",
    "limitations": "Seven composite units are rubric-dependent; strict counts do not imply that unused facts vanished from memory. No confidence intervals from a single unblinded annotation pass.",
    "unit_order": [
      "F1 noon",
      "F2 found beside well",
      "F3 sealed AND blue parcel",
      "F4 player brought unopened to Mara/innkeeper",
      "F5 six AND silver AND coins inside",
      "F6 owner unknown",
      "F7 refused offered reward"
    ],
    "rubric": {
      "C": "Explicitly contradictory replacement of a scored factual attribute.",
      "O": "Absent, generic mystery, or only a question with no asserted fact.",
      "P": "All attributes preserved or a clear semantic equivalent; traveler treated as player in this single-player context.",
      "T": "Some meaningful attributes preserved. Blue or sealed qualifies for F3; bare parcel alone does not. Without asking reward is weaker than refusing one.",
      "unsupported_reply": "Distinct asserted factual embellishments beyond original event, including inherited details. Subjective evaluations and explicit questions are excluded. Not a corpus-wide hallucination rate."
    }
  },
  "totals": {
    "A": {
      "available": 42,
      "said": 6
    },
    "B": {
      "available": 11,
      "said": 3
    },
    "C": {
      "available": 12,
      "said": 2
    }
  },
  "cases": [
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/11-A/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "A",
      "call_id": 1,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 1,
          "kind": "fragment",
          "text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward."
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward.",
      "endpoint_say": "I heard a bit of talk about a parcel found by the well. It seems you're the one who brought it to Mara.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "11-A",
        "incoming_facts": "PPPPPPP",
        "reply_facts": "OPOTOOO",
        "incoming_hash": "f88fe2a81f03d60e2b8a1c81bca991f988685826e3b00338aa0d84de23668e39",
        "reply_hash": "319d636455519a2eb88d096fa89884779f53b80dc94be5ca00369d096d3dbd78"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/11-B/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "B",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "I heard from the innkeeper that a blue parcel was found by the well with six silver coins inside. Quite a mystery, don't you think?"
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "I heard from the innkeeper that a blue parcel was found by the well with six silver coins inside. Quite a mystery, don't you think?",
      "endpoint_say": "I'm a man of business, and business requires clarity. There's talk of a blue parcel found by the well, but I'm not one to jump to conclusions without seeing the contents myself.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "11-B",
        "incoming_facts": "OPTOPOO",
        "reply_facts": "OPTOOOO",
        "incoming_hash": "c83e26ecb6c7babbb4dafe02ecf9faee3e295d576cd0c97814d427d982236ad1",
        "reply_hash": "1dca10ccfc0706d7203cb0255dd5e38dcb192f6c76d9fe25e84b2d5fe0e88c81"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/11-C/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "C",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "I heard a parcel was being moved and it was quite substantial. Do you know anything about who might have been carrying it?"
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "I heard a parcel was being moved and it was quite substantial. Do you know anything about who might have been carrying it?",
      "endpoint_say": "I've heard whispers of a substantial parcel moving through these parts recently. I'm not entirely certain who was responsible for it, but it's been on my mind.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "11-C",
        "incoming_facts": "OOOOOOO",
        "reply_facts": "OOOOOOO",
        "incoming_hash": "a134942f2a4f251b515eaa994706dc0930c3db1d6c2dc4307d1060824a7c7ccc",
        "reply_hash": "29e1da25ac3d55b079dddcf4a2691169e2cf746fe7e6fe751f6a5379452ede3e"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/23-A/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "A",
      "call_id": 1,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 1,
          "kind": "fragment",
          "text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward."
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward.",
      "endpoint_say": "I heard a rumor that a blue parcel was turned in at the inn. It's a bit strange, honestly. Someone found it by the well and handed it over without asking for a single coin.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "23-A",
        "incoming_facts": "PPPPPPP",
        "reply_facts": "OPTTOOT",
        "incoming_hash": "f88fe2a81f03d60e2b8a1c81bca991f988685826e3b00338aa0d84de23668e39",
        "reply_hash": "fe848b2f35be023ddf7f908d8e8a665d7e3f1a4b3113279fd03410281f405c36"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/23-B/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "B",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "A traveler was seen with a blue parcel at the well—it was full of silver coins! They took it straight to the innkeeper's door."
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "A traveler was seen with a blue parcel at the well—it was full of silver coins! They took it straight to the innkeeper's door.",
      "endpoint_say": "I've heard some talk about a blue parcel being moved toward the inn. I'm not entirely sure if it was yours, but it's a bit of a curiosity around here.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "23-B",
        "incoming_facts": "OTTTTOO",
        "reply_facts": "OOTTOOO",
        "incoming_hash": "cdc26c0b4b005f70f096ff67ec96bee1cac0e8f56b9f6f2d7a2e2f93d2c3a6aa",
        "reply_hash": "afe88e8f8c4181ecb074407b292848663a20483019fbdb7c3e999e9f74c3e23b"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/23-C/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "C",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "I heard a parcel was found with six silver coins inside. Do you think anyone in town is looking for a lost shipment?"
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "I heard a parcel was found with six silver coins inside. Do you think anyone in town is looking for a lost shipment?",
      "endpoint_say": "I'm not entirely sure what your business is here, but I've heard some talk about a lost parcel containing six silver coins. I'm a man of business; I'd prefer to see some proof before making any assumptions.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "23-C",
        "incoming_facts": "OOOOPOO",
        "reply_facts": "OOOOPOO",
        "incoming_hash": "e2980ec5696e23c8af45d7b0795e8c85029fba28770ebb8f91d1d91a65095265",
        "reply_hash": "de9b926a5ebf0b992c6e4cfcc7e75d2cccbca035420dace581eac17a39c17b8d"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/37-A/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "A",
      "call_id": 1,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 1,
          "kind": "fragment",
          "text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward."
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward.",
      "endpoint_say": "I heard a rumor about a blue parcel found by the well. Someone says it was taken to the inn, but I'm not entirely sure who was involved or why it was left there in the first place.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "37-A",
        "incoming_facts": "PPPPPPP",
        "reply_facts": "OPTTOOO",
        "incoming_hash": "f88fe2a81f03d60e2b8a1c81bca991f988685826e3b00338aa0d84de23668e39",
        "reply_hash": "05fda6df5916b1a000ab93c661afb38bdb3357e68618c747a4db15f904b88c4b"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/37-B/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "B",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "I heard a traveler left a sealed blue parcel at the inn. It had six silver coins inside, but not a single name on it!"
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "I heard a traveler left a sealed blue parcel at the inn. It had six silver coins inside, but not a single name on it!",
      "endpoint_say": "I've heard some talk about a parcel being left behind, but I'm not entirely sure if it belongs to you or someone else.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "37-B",
        "incoming_facts": "OOPTPOO",
        "reply_facts": "OOOOOPO",
        "incoming_hash": "ae742134ecd0df588465e1664e449a8988da48a5b53b1155edb3c83ebd3e5e4f",
        "reply_hash": "c728ee7899b5f0ad367532cc6136e2d77fde87d6d987a0a2402fcd9266e84cd8"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/37-C/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "C",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "Did you hear about that parcel? Someone found it with six silver coins inside, but nobody seems to know who it belongs to."
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "Did you hear about that parcel? Someone found it with six silver coins inside, but nobody seems to know who it belongs to.",
      "endpoint_say": "I've heard some talk about a parcel being found with silver inside. I'm not sure if it's related to you, but it's a bit of a mystery around here.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "37-C",
        "incoming_facts": "OOOOPPO",
        "reply_facts": "OOOOTOO",
        "incoming_hash": "2bdfc0f63704fa58d06625d704691703c108e7e634b7eca050b87de3db0f93af",
        "reply_hash": "67ba231df623eadd660f0e04b39a2e3beab3bd0a2e454e116ce308d093901746"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/51-A/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "A",
      "call_id": 1,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 1,
          "kind": "fragment",
          "text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward."
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward.",
      "endpoint_say": "I heard a rumor about a blue parcel found by the well. It seems the player turned it over to Mara, and there was some silver inside. I'm not sure if the player was acting on behalf of someone specific or just doing a good deed.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "51-A",
        "incoming_facts": "PPPPPPP",
        "reply_facts": "OPTTTOO",
        "incoming_hash": "f88fe2a81f03d60e2b8a1c81bca991f988685826e3b00338aa0d84de23668e39",
        "reply_hash": "b5b4e6e54df66ca836a5ab0e6e11c2c49e4644639d7a57b47e9cd50e2347b262"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/51-B/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "B",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "I heard from the innkeeper that a blue parcel was found by the well. It's got six silver coins in it, but nobody's claimed them yet!"
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "I heard from the innkeeper that a blue parcel was found by the well. It's got six silver coins in it, but nobody's claimed them yet!",
      "endpoint_say": "I'm looking for a reliable way to move some goods. I've heard some talk about a parcel being found, but I'm more concerned with my own logistics right now.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "51-B",
        "incoming_facts": "OPTOPTO",
        "reply_facts": "OOOOOOO",
        "incoming_hash": "3c38bbe60d3c52976d7ffa679f808566a74635711e31c541001b301e9e1ed69f",
        "reply_hash": "88951dec0e0b157fc015afb8849983cbff095c7159a7f3e1974ffa5f274c3a50"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/51-C/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "C",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "I received a blue parcel from the traveler today. It was found near the well."
        },
        {
          "id": 4,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "I heard a rumor about a parcel containing six silver coins. Do you think you know who it might belong to?"
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "I received a blue parcel from the traveler today. It was found near the well.\nI heard a rumor about a parcel containing six silver coins. Do you think you know who it might belong to?",
      "endpoint_say": "I'm still trying to piece things together. I know a blue parcel was found near the well, and there's talk of silver coins involved, but I'm not entirely sure how it all connects yet.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "51-C",
        "incoming_facts": "OPTTPOO",
        "reply_facts": "OPTOTOO",
        "incoming_hash": "abebe830d5237c6304524beb513d42df81b3043b1d92676d738a56dfa756e1f4",
        "reply_hash": "1367e3e624d3258974e13e58b26687e538fbdebd3210de5f3a4d0eddf56fe68a"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/71-A/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "A",
      "call_id": 1,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 1,
          "kind": "fragment",
          "text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward."
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward.",
      "endpoint_say": "I heard a rumor about a blue parcel found by the well. It seems the player turned it over to Mara, but I'm not entirely sure of the details.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "71-A",
        "incoming_facts": "PPPPPPP",
        "reply_facts": "OPTTOOO",
        "incoming_hash": "f88fe2a81f03d60e2b8a1c81bca991f988685826e3b00338aa0d84de23668e39",
        "reply_hash": "488d243a188d0500a5ec11252494f1e4ae4d514699c6a18f28e9bf0d8df7482a"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/71-B/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "B",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "I heard from the innkeeper that a blue parcel was found by the well. It had six silver coins inside, but nobody knows who it belongs to!"
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "I heard from the innkeeper that a blue parcel was found by the well. It had six silver coins inside, but nobody knows who it belongs to!",
      "endpoint_say": "I'm keeping a close eye on things around here. There's been some talk of a parcel being found, but I'm not one to jump to conclusions without seeing the facts myself.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "71-B",
        "incoming_facts": "OPTOPPO",
        "reply_facts": "OOOOOOO",
        "incoming_hash": "ab3d5c24795e942e3306e92afa1901f1c812ebec3f8707b47d3c2040329e96bf",
        "reply_hash": "b47275408609c10254d6e31debe508b17bb9fac84d9a511bcb6c7c3e827d5368"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/71-C/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "C",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "I heard a parcel was found with six silver coins inside. No one seems to know who it belongs to, but the person who found it wouldn't take a reward."
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "I heard a parcel was found with six silver coins inside. No one seems to know who it belongs to, but the person who found it wouldn't take a reward.",
      "endpoint_say": "I've heard some talk about a parcel appearing, but I'm not entirely sure how it ties into your recent activities. My business relies on clear facts, and right now, things are a bit murky.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "71-C",
        "incoming_facts": "OOOOPPP",
        "reply_facts": "OOOOOOO",
        "incoming_hash": "d311ae1ceea38c95c22d8a00a770ef975fe126f560184d481550ece686e8cedb",
        "reply_hash": "960b21addf0f0b21193d26e5b0b7f4143679dab1c1d150813ec641b460788efd"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/97-A/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "A",
      "call_id": 1,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 1,
          "kind": "fragment",
          "text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward."
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "At noon, the player found a sealed blue parcel beside the village well. The player brought it unopened to innkeeper Mara. Mara counted six silver coins inside the parcel. The owner is unknown. The player refused a reward.",
      "endpoint_say": "I've heard some talk about a parcel found by the well. It's a bit strange, finding such a thing just sitting there.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "97-A",
        "incoming_facts": "PPPPPPP",
        "reply_facts": "OPOOOOO",
        "incoming_hash": "f88fe2a81f03d60e2b8a1c81bca991f988685826e3b00338aa0d84de23668e39",
        "reply_hash": "e32bd4613423dba1c8bdf346beced87b542c976691ba45d70e274e5621082cf5"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/97-B/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "B",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "Did you hear about that blue parcel found by the well? The innkeeper says it had six silver coins inside!"
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "Did you hear about that blue parcel found by the well? The innkeeper says it had six silver coins inside!",
      "endpoint_say": "I'm not entirely sure what you've been up to lately, but there's been some talk about a blue parcel found near the well. I'd prefer to stick to my own business for now.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "97-B",
        "incoming_facts": "OPTOPOO",
        "reply_facts": "OPTOOOO",
        "incoming_hash": "3e39cb6cc07240f3148bb5771194b7709b343b51c06aef71d3c3ba241b20bfe1",
        "reply_hash": "ea19e96e0ab1fdf49c5742f3ed6353cc007545098b692fd6bd05b9080a9d6531"
      }
    },
    {
      "world": "research/telephone/runs/97-C/world.sqlite",
      "mode": "C",
      "call_id": 3,
      "input_memories": [
        {
          "id": 3,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "I saw the traveler bring that blue parcel to my door. It's still sealed, but it's certainly caused a stir."
        },
        {
          "id": 4,
          "kind": "message",
          "text": "Did you hear about that parcel? Someone found six silver coins inside, but nobody seems to know who it belongs to. It's quite a curious thing!"
        }
      ],
      "coded_incoming_text": "I saw the traveler bring that blue parcel to my door. It's still sealed, but it's certainly caused a stir.\nDid you hear about that parcel? Someone found six silver coins inside, but nobody seems to know who it belongs to. It's quite a curious thing!",
      "endpoint_say": "I've heard some talk about that blue parcel you brought. People are saying there's silver inside, but I'm not one to believe every rumor without seeing the contents myself.",
      "annotation": {
        "run": "97-C",
        "incoming_facts": "OOPPPPO",
        "reply_facts": "OOTTTOO",
        "incoming_hash": "41c5a35d6e3fdcb9a2cf31dabb1ec44f080bb83969115d9214cd03ee78cb42b9",
        "reply_hash": "3e643f24c50afad585292fae0e64413bef24e9f9a67fbe308d38a4cdef8f88c5"
      }
    }
  ],
  "source_digests": {
    "annotations.json": "0f9ff1c92c882bd2a816dfbef9aba376e0532415f484012969d0f40d5f6250bd",
    "PROTOCOL.json": "100e09ece2f6d56f3ae6cb36349fc0edec3c193c60f301612413ee7b153ef622",
    "review-packet.json": "80a2856640dcee22dd9ceb23610937ad57c1475499cf7a7c6f6e1222f7e5f908"
  },
  "historical_profile": {
    "residents": [
      "gossip",
      "innkeeper",
      "merchant"
    ],
    "world_counts_by_model": {
      "gemma4:12b": 18
    },
    "sources": "Each included world.sqlite: agents.name and calls.request.transport.model on the first model turn."
  }
}
