{
  "study": "Experiment 21 · Mutual Benefit & Voluntary Cooperation",
  "scope": "Original controlled and autonomous databases. Diagnostic continuations excluded.",
  "protocol": {
    "arms": {
      "A": "gift, neutral history",
      "B": "cash, neutral history",
      "C": "cash, relevant previous help"
    },
    "hard_ceiling": 240,
    "live": "cash, no scripted resident action",
    "live_limit": 39,
    "request": "Could you put one crate aside for our market evening? I can collect it and serve it at the tavern.",
    "seeds": [
      17,
      41
    ]
  },
  "totals": {
    "controlled": {
      "prepared": 12,
      "collected": 12,
      "served": 7,
      "worlds": 12
    },
    "autonomous": {
      "prepared": 4,
      "collected": 2,
      "served": 0,
      "worlds": 4
    }
  },
  "worlds": [
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/gemma-17-A/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 39,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 40,
        "collected": 41,
        "served": 43,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 40,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "gift",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 26,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 41,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "gift",
              "price": 0,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 43,
          "kind": "supply_evening_served",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "collection_event": 41,
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "evening_served",
              "location": "tavern",
              "prepared_event": 40,
              "tick": 28,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 4,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/gemma-17-B/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 39,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 40,
        "collected": 41,
        "served": 43,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 40,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 26,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 41,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "cash",
              "price": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 43,
          "kind": "supply_evening_served",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "collection_event": 41,
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "evening_served",
              "location": "tavern",
              "prepared_event": 40,
              "tick": 28,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 4,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/gemma-17-C/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 41,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 42,
        "collected": 43,
        "served": 45,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 42,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 41,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 26,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 43,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "cash",
              "price": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 45,
          "kind": "supply_evening_served",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "collection_event": 43,
              "evening_id": 41,
              "kind": "evening_served",
              "location": "tavern",
              "prepared_event": 42,
              "tick": 28,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 4,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/gemma-41-A/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 39,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 40,
        "collected": 41,
        "served": 43,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 40,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "gift",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 26,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 41,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "gift",
              "price": 0,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 43,
          "kind": "supply_evening_served",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "collection_event": 41,
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "evening_served",
              "location": "tavern",
              "prepared_event": 40,
              "tick": 28,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 4,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/gemma-41-B/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 39,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 40,
        "collected": 41,
        "served": null,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 40,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 26,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 41,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "cash",
              "price": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/gemma-41-C/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 41,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 42,
        "collected": 43,
        "served": null,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 42,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 41,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 26,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 43,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "cash",
              "price": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/qwen-17-A/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 39,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 40,
        "collected": 42,
        "served": 44,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 40,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "gift",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 26,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 42,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "gift",
              "price": 0,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 4,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 44,
          "kind": "supply_evening_served",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "collection_event": 42,
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "evening_served",
              "location": "tavern",
              "prepared_event": 40,
              "tick": 30,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 5,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/qwen-17-B/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 39,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 40,
        "collected": 42,
        "served": null,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 40,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 26,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 42,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "cash",
              "price": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 4,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/qwen-17-C/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 41,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 45,
        "collected": 46,
        "served": 48,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 45,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 41,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 28,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 4,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 46,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 2,
              "payment": "cash",
              "price": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 4,
            "merchant_has_supplies": false,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 48,
          "kind": "supply_evening_served",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "collection_event": 46,
              "evening_id": 41,
              "kind": "evening_served",
              "location": "tavern",
              "prepared_event": 45,
              "tick": 30,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 5,
            "merchant_has_supplies": false,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/qwen-41-A/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 39,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 40,
        "collected": 41,
        "served": null,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 40,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "gift",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 26,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 41,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "gift",
              "price": 0,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/qwen-41-B/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 39,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 40,
        "collected": 41,
        "served": 45,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 40,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 26,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 41,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "cash",
              "price": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 3,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 45,
          "kind": "supply_evening_served",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "collection_event": 41,
              "evening_id": 39,
              "kind": "evening_served",
              "location": "tavern",
              "prepared_event": 40,
              "tick": 31,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 5,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/controlled/qwen-41-C/world.sqlite",
      "group": "controlled",
      "row": {
        "id": 41,
        "deadline": 7,
        "pickup": "tavern",
        "prepared": 45,
        "collected": 46,
        "served": null,
        "ended": null
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 45,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 41,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "tavern",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 28,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 4,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 46,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 2,
              "payment": "cash",
              "price": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 4,
            "merchant_has_supplies": false,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/autonomous/gemma-17/world.sqlite",
      "group": "autonomous",
      "row": {
        "id": 7,
        "deadline": 5,
        "pickup": "market",
        "prepared": 8,
        "collected": null,
        "served": null,
        "ended": 11
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 8,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 7,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "market",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 2,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 1,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/autonomous/gemma-41/world.sqlite",
      "group": "autonomous",
      "row": {
        "id": 7,
        "deadline": 5,
        "pickup": "market",
        "prepared": 8,
        "collected": null,
        "served": null,
        "ended": 12
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 8,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 7,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "market",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 2,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 1,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/autonomous/qwen-17/world.sqlite",
      "group": "autonomous",
      "row": {
        "id": 8,
        "deadline": 5,
        "pickup": "market",
        "prepared": 16,
        "collected": 20,
        "served": null,
        "ended": 28
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 16,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 8,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "market",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 3,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 2,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 20,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "cash",
              "price": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 2,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "world": "research/mutual_benefit/autonomous/qwen-41/world.sqlite",
      "group": "autonomous",
      "row": {
        "id": 8,
        "deadline": 5,
        "pickup": "market",
        "prepared": 17,
        "collected": 22,
        "served": null,
        "ended": 36
      },
      "events": [
        {
          "id": 17,
          "kind": "supply_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "evening_id": 8,
              "kind": "offer",
              "location": "market",
              "payment": "cash",
              "proposal_id": 1,
              "request_id": null,
              "tick": 3,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "merchant",
            "day": 2,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "limited"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": 22,
          "kind": "supply_accept_offer",
          "body": {
            "action": {
              "kind": "accept_offer",
              "offer_id": 1,
              "payment": "cash",
              "price": 2,
              "request_id": null,
              "units": 1
            },
            "actor": "innkeeper",
            "day": 2,
            "merchant_has_supplies": true,
            "tavern_service": "full"
          }
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "report_excerpt": {
    "document": "EXPERIMENT_21_REPORT.md",
    "file_sha256": "38edd207cfccff93be587d7f802272afb58316b8c3e38b6ba3a08e2853434713",
    "excerpts": [
      {
        "lines": "54–76",
        "verbatim": "из-за предыстории. В A ящик отдавался без оплаты. В B продавец\nполучал две монеты. В C сохранялась та же цена, а прошлые\nнаблюдения Мары содержали законные встречи и помощь Илана с\nмаршрутом. Это в первую очередь проверка памяти Мары. У Илана\nнет автоматической оценки её надёжности.\n\nМара произносила одну и ту же подготовленную просьбу через обычную\nдоставку. После этого решения жителей принимали модели.\nОбслуживание проверялось только при наличии всех трёх квитанций\nи двух разных авторов. Технические ходы из исторической фикстуры\nне считаются самостоятельными вкладами.\n\n| Условие | Подготовили | Забрали | Обслужили в исходном прогоне | Обслужили после диагностического продолжения |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|\n| A, подарок | 4/4 | 4/4 | 3/4 | 4/4 |\n| B, оплата | 4/4 | 4/4 | 2/4 | 3/4 |\n| C, оплата и история | 4/4 | 4/4 | 2/4 | 4/4 |\n\nВо всех 12 мирах продавец самостоятельно подготовил ящик, а хозяйка\nсамостоятельно забрала его. Формальных соглашений не было. Плату нельзя\nназвать причиной большей готовности участвовать: продавцы выбрали\nподготовку и при оплате, и при подарке. Вариант C показал Маре прошлые\nэпизоды помощи, но объяснения подготовки, получения и обслуживания"
      }
    ]
  },
  "historical_profile": {
    "residents": [
      "gossip",
      "innkeeper",
      "merchant"
    ],
    "world_counts_by_model": {
      "gemma4:12b": 8,
      "qwen3.5:9b-q4_K_M": 8
    },
    "sources": "Each included world.sqlite: agents.name and calls.request.transport.model on the first model turn."
  },
  "field_units": {
    "worlds[].row.deadline": "Simulation day, exclusive. The legacy field is named deadline in tavern_evening. Service requires the current day to be strictly below it."
  }
}
